Lid for a Box with Butterfly (1855–57): Art, History and Details

Lid for a Box with Butterfly (1855–57) is in the Cleveland Museum of Art collection. The museum's creator attribution is Seifū Yohei I (Japanese, 1801–1861).

The work and its context

The museum's open-access catalogue describes the work:

This sturdy box, with comparatively thick walls and resulting heft, is sparsely decorated with a single butterfly motif in dark underglaze blue cobalt in one corner of the lid and with repeating floral patterns along the lid and base. Single broken lines of underglaze blue define the edge of the box lid’s top where it curves to meet the sides and again where it meets the base of the box. Another blue band runs around the upper rim of the base where it meets the lip, left unglazed for a better grip of the lid when the box is closed. Yohei I’s signature on the center of the recessed base is set within a wide blue square. The porcelain box is meant to call to mind a famous story attributed to Zhuang Zhou (c. 369–286 BCE), also known as Master Zhuang, or Zhuangzi, pronounced Soji in Japanese. The second chapter of Zhuangzi, his eponymous collection of anecdotes, records the story as follows: Once, Zhuang Zhou dreamt he was a butterfly flitting and fluttering about, happy with himself and doing as he pleased. He didn’t know that he was Zhuang Zhou. Suddenly, he woke up and there he was, solid and unmistakably Zhuang Zhou. But he didn’t know if he was Zhuang Zhou who had dreamt he was a butterfly, or a butterfly dreaming that he was Zhuang Zhou. Between Zhuang Zhou and the butterfly there must be some distinction! This is called the Transformation of Things. The lidded box resembles kosometsuke, the porcelains in underglaze blue made to order or on speculation for the Japanese market during the early to mid-1600s in Jingdezhen, China. These works were often made from designs submitted by Japanese clients, many of whom were masters of chanoyu, who sought the wares for their tea practice. The relative roughness of the clay and the distortions in the fired object were intentional, as they created the rustic effect desired by Japanese tea communities.

Object facts

• Title: Lid for a Box with Butterfly
• Date: 1855–57
• Creator attribution: Seifū Yohei I (Japanese, 1801–1861)
• Culture: Japan, Meiji period (1868–1912)
• Type: Ceramic
• Technique: Porcelain with underglaze blue
• Collection: Japanese Art
• Department: Japanese Art
• Accession number: 2022.149.b

A detail from the museum

The bottom of the box is inscribed with the name Seifū.

Collection credit

Gift of James and Christine Heusinger

View the collection record

See the museum's photographs and full catalogue entry. Catalogue text is reproduced from the Cleveland Museum of Art's open-access data, with HTML formatting removed. This object and its supplied image are designated CC0.